Sovereign Immunity Or the Rule of Law: The New Federalism's Choice
Carolina Academic Press, 2005 - 254 pages
"Sovereign Immunity or the Rule of Law suggests a fresh look at the doctrine of sovereign immunity through the lens of political philosophers whose writings were well known to the people who framed and ratified the United States Constitution. Some of those philosophers espoused theories of sovereignty that logically compelled sovereign immunity. John Locke, the philosopher upon whom the former colonists predominantly relied, espoused a theory of sovereignty that, by contrast, cannot tolerate the idea of sovereign immunity - a government not answerable to its own laws or to the instrument that gave it life. Donald L. Doernberg argues that the United States Constitution exists for no purpose other than to restrain government power, and that to declare the government immune from accountability under it is a profanation of our political and philosophical history."--BOOK JACKET.
abstention accompanying text action activity Alden American apply approach argued assertion authority Bodin century citizens civil claims clear clearly command Commerce Clause common concept concern Congress consent constitutional contract course created criminal decision discussed dissenting doctrine effect Eleventh Amendment enforce English established example exercise exist federal courts federal government force hand Hobbes human idea important individual infra notes interest involved issue John judge judicial jurisdiction Justice king language least legislative limited Locke majority matter means ment nature never officials omitted opinion original permit person plaintiffs political position possible principle proceedings Professor protection Pufendorf question reason recognized referred regulate relief remedy respect result rule of law seeking society sovereign immunity sovereignty statute suit supra note Supreme Court things thought tion tort Tribe U.S. CONST United violated Young