The Double Face of Janus and Other Essays in the History of MedicineJHU Press, 2006 M11 2 - 560 pages Preeminent historian of medicine Owsei Temkin brought to his writing an awesome range of scholarship, for he was at home in the classical, the medieval, and the modern eras. The essays gathered in this volume deal with all the topics that Temkin considered most important in his work. They were widely commended for their originality, intelligent analysis, and impressive continuity of thought. Temkin explores the history of basic medical sciences, of health and disease, and of surgery and drug therapy, as well as general questions concerning the historical and philosophical approach to medicine from antiquity to the early twentieth century. In a retrospective introduction which gives the book its name, Temkin relates his writings to his career as a scholar in Germany and the United States. He situates the writings against the background of the development of the study of medical history and provides recollections of such prominent figures as Karl Sudhoff, Henry E. Sigerist, William H. Welch, and Richard H. Shryock. |
Contents
V | 25 |
The Meaning of Medicine in Historical Perspective | 41 |
Medicine and the Problem of Moral Responsibility | 50 |
An Essay on the Usefulness of Medical History for Medicine | 68 |
On the Interrelationship of the History and the Philosophy | 101 |
The Historiography of Ideas in Medicine | 110 |
Comparative Study in the History of Medicine | 126 |
Greek Medicine as Science and Craft | 137 |
Vesalius on an Immanent Biological Motor Force | 287 |
The Classical Roots of Glissons Doctrine of Irritation | 290 |
The Philosophical Background of Magendies Physiology | 317 |
Materialism in French and German Physiology of the Early Nineteenth Century | 340 |
Basic Science Medicine and the Romantic Era The Fielding H Garrison Lecture | 345 |
German Concepts of Ontogeny and History around 1800 | 373 |
The Idea of Descent in PostRomantic German Biology 1848 | 390 |
VI | 397 |
On Galens Pneumatology | 154 |
A Galenic Model for Quantitative Physiological Reasoning? | 162 |
Studies on Late Alexandrian Medicine I Alexandrian | 178 |
The Byzantine Origin of the Names for the Basilic | 198 |
IV | 206 |
RENAISSANCE TO TWENTIETH CENTURY | 223 |
Zimmermanns Philosophy of the Physician | 239 |
Wunderlich Schelling and the History of Medicine | 246 |
The European Background of the Young Dr Welch | 252 |
The Era of Paul Ehrlich | 261 |
BASIC MEDICAL SCIENCES AND BIOLOGY | 269 |
Metaphors of Human Biology | 271 |
Was Servetus Influenced by Ibn anNafis? | 284 |
HEALTH AND DISEASE | 417 |
Health and Disease | 419 |
Specific Entity and Individual Sickness | 441 |
An Historical Analysis of the Concept of Infection | 456 |
On the History of Morality and Syphilis | 472 |
SURGERY AND DRUG THERAPY | 485 |
The Role of Surgery in the Rise of Modern Medical Thought | 487 |
The Early History of Experimental Pylorectomy | 497 |
A Postscript to Merrems Youthful Dream | 510 |
Fernel Joubert and Erastus on the Specificity of Cathartic Drugs | 512 |
Therapeutic Trends and the Treatment of Syphilis before 1900 | 518 |
525 | |