HomeGroupsTalkMoreZeitgeist
Search Site
This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

The Unnatural History of the Sea: The Past…
Loading...

The Unnatural History of the Sea: The Past and Future of Humanity and Fishing (Gaia Thinking) (original 2007; edition 2007)

by CALLUM ROBERTS

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
2197122,418 (3.94)17
I read this a few years back but really loved it! ( )
  Pinniped23 | Sep 19, 2014 |
Showing 7 of 7
This book left me too angry and depressed to write coherently, so instead here's a brief glossary of terms which I hope might give you some idea why:
   trawling (technol.): a type of fishing in which the ocean floor is scraped clean, not only of fish, but of every living thing—vertebrate and invertebrate, coral, even chunks of the reefs themselves. An industry which extracts fish as a non-renewable resource, like coal or oil. Underwater strip-mining on a near-global scale.
   ghost fishing (technol.): the stuff of nightmares. A process whereby a length of abandoned gill-netting, perhaps miles long and either lost during fishing or deliberately dumped overboard at the end of a trip, continues to fish. It stands upright on the seabed snaring everything which swims, floats or crawls into it—fish, turtles, dolphins, everything. Eventually the sheer weight of corpses forces the net down flat. The bodies then rot and are scavenged by crabs until, released, the netting stands back up again. The whole process is then repeated, again and again...indefinitely. Losing and dumping fishing gear is routine, so the world's oceans are littered with these perpetual death-traps.
   inrage (psychol.): similar to, but the opposite of, outrage; what happens inside your head at the precise moment you read about trawlermen complaining that their nets are often damaged by coral reefs.
   dodo (zoolog.): an extinct species of flightless bird, wiped out in a manner which we moderns condemn while, simultaneously, treating the entire biosphere with the same ignorance and contempt.
   bluefin (zoolog.): a species of tuna, formerly abundant, but now rapidly following the dodo into oblivion. So scarce and valuable has it become, that it is now worth using sonar, helicopters and even spotter planes to locate individual fish then guide the boats in for the kill. As Callum Roberts puts it: "This isn't fishing any more, it's the extermination of a species."
   money (econ.): the system of exchange responsible for this madness: as a commodity becomes ever rarer, so its price rises to ridiculous levels. The last bluefin tuna of all—worth millions—will also be the most ruthlessly pursued.
   growth (econ., as in economic growth):the process by which everything shrinks except the size of the human population.
   marine nature reserves (ecolog.): one of the most bizarre concepts ever devised by the imagination, apparently—politicians in particular find it utterly incomprehensible.
   shifting environmental baselines (psychol.): the conceptual flaw at the heart of this apocalypse. Each fresh generation of Homo sapiens sees only its own small section of the decline; there's little perception of the longer-term depletion, and none whatever of the original superabundance (at times "more fish than water") which existed back at the start before human beings began plundering it. This flaw is found even amongst ecologists who study what is left of these ecosystems; thus conservationists work back to "baselines" which aren't meaningful baselines at all, just slightly earlier points back up the slope—points which, moreover, creep downhill from one decade to the next.
   Homo sapiens (zoolog.): arguably the least intelligent of the primates; the only one, arboreal or otherwise, currently sawing through the very branch it is sitting on.
   Earth (astron.): third planet of eight orbiting a G-class main-sequence star midway between 61 Cygni and Sirius. An ocean planet (71% of its surface area). Abundant life, but currently in the throes of its sixth (and primarily marine) mass-extinction event.
   The Unnatural History of the Sea by Callum Roberts (bibliog.): a meticulously detailed—and relentless—book by a leading authority on the subject. Reduced this reader, during its second half in particular, to despair.
   despair (psychol.): a state of mind, impossible to express in a mere book review (perhaps impossible in words at all), in which you find you no longer care what happens to the human race, but that what is being done to the beautiful Earth fills you with sorrow. ( )
1 vote justlurking | Jul 4, 2021 |
I had previously read [b:The Sea Around Us|542766|The Sea Around Us|Rachel Carson|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1349123606s/542766.jpg|2423508] by Rachel Carson, which had by far the deepest impact on me of any book about the ocean I have ever read, and revolutionized the way I perceived the ocean. I had also previously read [b:Moby-Duck: The True Story of 28,800 Bath Toys Lost at Sea and of the Beachcombers, Oceanographers, Environmentalists, and Fools, Including the Author, Who Went in Search of Them|9595216|Moby-Duck The True Story of 28,800 Bath Toys Lost at Sea and of the Beachcombers, Oceanographers, Environmentalists, and Fools, Including the Author, Who Went in Search of Them|Donovan Hohn|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1347689267s/9595216.jpg|14482244], which introduced me to the Great Garbage Patch and many other negative impacts humans have had on the ocean, so this book was not quite the shock to me that it appears to have been to many other reviewers. However, it is considerably blunter than either of the other two, and becoming livid with outrage over the atrocities perpetrated against the ocean and its life would not be an unreasonable reaction to reading it. I would definitely recommend it for the complacent and people who just don’t know, as well as for those interested in “natural” history.

Roberts gives a fine portrayal of the disastrous human interaction with oceanic life throughout history and even prehistory, and I was surprised to learn how far back overfishing and over-exploiting the ocean really goes. Before I read this I thought of overfishing as having begun in the twentieth century, or maybe a little earlier if whaling is included. I had no idea that whaling had begun as early as the Neolithic – there are rock carvings in South Korea dating from 6000 to 1000 BC that portray people in boats pursuing whales in enough detail that individual species can be identified. The overfishing of European waters began during the Middle Ages, and because of factors as diverse as Viking invasions, the dietary requirements of the Catholic Church, the clearing of land for agriculture, and the damming of rivers for gristmills and aquaculture. Meanwhile, governments tried to ban or at least decrease overfishing as early as 1289, using surprisingly modern reasoning. King Phillip IV of France cited a mixture of health, economic, and environmental concerns in his decree against it: “the fish are prevented by them [the fishing industry] from growing to their proper condition, nor have the fish any value when caught by them, nor are they good for human consumption, but rather bad, and further it happens that they are much more costly than they used to be…”

I also thought of trawler fishing as a twentieth-century development, but it began in the 1300’s, and as early as 1376 there were petitions to ban the practice in English waters. The efforts were in vain, and trawler fishing continues to be used today even though it is vastly destructive to the ocean floor, and has been compared to strip mining. Roberts doesn’t stop there, stating that trawling is “leveling unknown Yellowstone Parks.”

However, the book closes on a note of hope, which I believe as very important because a lot of times hope is what keeps people going. And there is some reason for it, especially if we can constructively channel our outrage over how the ocean has been treated in the past, and start recognizing the ocean as the extraordinary place it really is.
( )
  Jennifer708 | Mar 21, 2020 |
I had previously read [b:The Sea Around Us|542766|The Sea Around Us|Rachel Carson|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1349123606s/542766.jpg|2423508] by Rachel Carson, which had by far the deepest impact on me of any book about the ocean I have ever read, and revolutionized the way I perceived the ocean. I had also previously read [b:Moby-Duck: The True Story of 28,800 Bath Toys Lost at Sea and of the Beachcombers, Oceanographers, Environmentalists, and Fools, Including the Author, Who Went in Search of Them|9595216|Moby-Duck The True Story of 28,800 Bath Toys Lost at Sea and of the Beachcombers, Oceanographers, Environmentalists, and Fools, Including the Author, Who Went in Search of Them|Donovan Hohn|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1347689267s/9595216.jpg|14482244], which introduced me to the Great Garbage Patch and many other negative impacts humans have had on the ocean, so this book was not quite the shock to me that it appears to have been to many other reviewers. However, it is considerably blunter than either of the other two, and becoming livid with outrage over the atrocities perpetrated against the ocean and its life would not be an unreasonable reaction to reading it. I would definitely recommend it for the complacent and people who just don’t know, as well as for those interested in “natural” history.

Roberts gives a fine portrayal of the disastrous human interaction with oceanic life throughout history and even prehistory, and I was surprised to learn how far back overfishing and over-exploiting the ocean really goes. Before I read this I thought of overfishing as having begun in the twentieth century, or maybe a little earlier if whaling is included. I had no idea that whaling had begun as early as the Neolithic – there are rock carvings in South Korea dating from 6000 to 1000 BC that portray people in boats pursuing whales in enough detail that individual species can be identified. The overfishing of European waters began during the Middle Ages, and because of factors as diverse as Viking invasions, the dietary requirements of the Catholic Church, the clearing of land for agriculture, and the damming of rivers for gristmills and aquaculture. Meanwhile, governments tried to ban or at least decrease overfishing as early as 1289, using surprisingly modern reasoning. King Phillip IV of France cited a mixture of health, economic, and environmental concerns in his decree against it: “the fish are prevented by them [the fishing industry] from growing to their proper condition, nor have the fish any value when caught by them, nor are they good for human consumption, but rather bad, and further it happens that they are much more costly than they used to be…”

I also thought of trawler fishing as a twentieth-century development, but it began in the 1300’s, and as early as 1376 there were petitions to ban the practice in English waters. The efforts were in vain, and trawler fishing continues to be used today even though it is vastly destructive to the ocean floor, and has been compared to strip mining. Roberts doesn’t stop there, stating that trawling is “leveling unknown Yellowstone Parks.”

However, the book closes on a note of hope, which I believe as very important because a lot of times hope is what keeps people going. And there is some reason for it, especially if we can constructively channel our outrage over how the ocean has been treated in the past, and start recognizing the ocean as the extraordinary place it really is.
( )
  Jennifer708 | Mar 21, 2020 |
I read this a few years back but really loved it! ( )
  Pinniped23 | Sep 19, 2014 |
With The Unnatural History of the Sea, Callum Roberts extensively documents the destructiveness and shortsightedness that fishing has generally had on the abundance, distribution, and diversity of marine life in many of the world’s oceans over centuries. The concerned tone is justified by the vast evidence synthesized throughout which provides a picture of how paltry today’s oceanic cornucopia is compared to historical plenty. After all, we’ve been fishing down the food web while shifting our baselines – and it’s just not a good combination for either the fish or ourselves.

One of the main strengths of this book that I enjoyed was the juxtaposition of contemporary historical reports from ships logs and private journals with modern scientific understanding of fishery stocks, their changes over time, and the factors that influence them. For example, Roberts often relates observations by William Dampier. Dampier was a “extraordinary man. Born in the west country of England around 1650, he was in the course of his colorful career a planter, logwood cutter, pirate, navigator, hydrographer, sea captain, diplomat, explorer, naturalist, writer, and relentless traveler. By the age of sixty, three years before his death, he had circumnavigated the globe three times.” And there are tons of interesting people like that whose observations contribute to the briny riches that this book describes.

Roberts also relates personal observations by himself and other scientists focused on coral reefs, marine parks, kelp forests, and other exotic ecosystems. This book roams across the seas, delving into the fates of cod, herring, swordfish, seals, whales, coral reefs, Chesapeake Bay striped bass and oysters, and the deep dark places which we still know little about.

Despite the broad range of topics Roberts covers, at times the book felt cyclical and repetitive. Yet unlike books of poorer quality, recurrence is not due to poor writing but rather the depressingly destructive cycle with eerie repetitiveness across the ‘seven seas’ over time. As Roberts patently shows, historical abundance of near-shore fisheries dwindles as fishing intensity increases, followed by a switch of targeted species to previously less valuable ones and/or improvements to fishing technology until resources are depleted at which point fishing grounds move to deeper waters further offshore. Fish stock impoverishment is often masked by changes to practices (e.g. technological advancements or opening novel fishing areas) or reporting (e.g. lumping multiple species or fish of different ages together). Roberts further makes the connection that a mismatch of communication, interests, and timing often confound efforts of scientists, fishery managers, and politicians from fixing the problems or even getting a clear picture of the extent of the problem.

While it’s a depressing taken as a whole of fishing history, the book does not end there. He envisions a future global fishery turned on its head and points out seven ways to get there. These are:
1. Reduce present fishing capacity
2. Eliminate risk-prone decision making
3. Eliminate catch quotas and implement controls on the amount of fishing
4. Require people to keep what they catch
5. Require fishers to use gear modified to reduce bycatch
6. Ban or restrict the most damaging catching methods
7. Implement extensive networks of marine reserves off-limits to fishing

I’ll let Roberts expound and explain these himself. You’ll just have to read the book. ( )
3 vote GoofyOcean110 | Dec 28, 2010 |
The Unnatural History of the Sea hits all my geek buttons: the author mines historical sources to reconstruct the natural world of the past, has a strong grasp of current research on ecosystem resiliency, and peppers the text with observations from his own research. The thesis of the book is that fishing has had an unimaginably large impact on the earth, most of which has gone unnoticed because of shifting baselines.

Part of me wants to quibble with the titular use of "unnatural" - why are humans always exempted from natural history as if we were aliens? But part of me couldn't think of a better title, either. ( )
2 vote bexaplex | Dec 17, 2009 |
This really is a fascinating and beautifully argued book. I chanced across it because I had been disappointed by Jared Diamond's Collapse and wanted to find something that dealt more rigorously with humans' approach to natural resource management. I know very little about the specifics of marine resources, but, as a detailed and specific, though very readable, case study, this way outclassed Diamond's offering. One of Roberts' more interesting points (though in retrospect it's an obvious one) is how processes of environmental change that outlast an individual's lifespan are underestimated because we assume that what we're used to is what has always been. We may notice limited change over our own lifetime, but this record is not passed on to subsequent generations. The result, after successive historic waves of marine exploitation, is that the species, volumes and sizes of fish we currently catch would have been laughed at by our 18th Century, and found totally incredible by our medievil, ancestors. Many of the detailed and well argued lessons that Roberts draws are very much applicable to other types of natural resources (minerals, energy, carbon absorbtive capacity). ( )
2 vote DavidHumphrey | Dec 2, 2008 |
Showing 7 of 7

Current Discussions

None

Popular covers

Quick Links

Rating

Average: (3.94)
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5 1
3 4
3.5 1
4 6
4.5 2
5 4

Is this you?

Become a LibraryThing Author.

 

About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 203,243,239 books! | Top bar: Always visible